Jump to content
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

cincydave8

Cincinnati: West End: FC Cincinnati Stadium

Recommended Posts

Futbol Club Cincinnati nearing finalization of stadium plans in Cincinnati?

 

https://www.cincinnati.com/story/sports/soccer/fc-cincinnati/2017/11/08/oakley-community-council-votes-favor-fc-cincinnati-stadium/846783001/

 

FCC plans to announce stadium most likely at the Milacron/Fast Cab location in Oakley. They have a vote of support from Oakley CC and are putting up $300 Million dollars. It also appears they're not asking for money to build the stadium but maybe help with tax abetments. Oakley has always been an option and after the backlash they received from (some) fans about Newport they've been focusing on Cincinnati. The West End site is probably just too much to get it done. Of course, a lot of people will complain about Oakley and traffic and not being urban enough. But this is big news.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Wow, that actually really is going to crush traffic in that area.  It's cool they are going to be able to do this but I was kind of hoping for Newport site, to give a bigger jolt to downtown and Newport area that really needs it.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I am not sure how you execute this plan without some reconfiguration of that Ridge exit (or some other additional access to 71/Norwood Lateral).  I know there are modifications coming for the Ridge interchange in 2018.

 

Traffic is an absolute mess around there when Crossroads lets out on Sunday's and that's at most a few thousand people (I think?).

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Newport is a much better choice. Keep it downtown. If you cant do OTR, go to Ovation. Oakley will be a horrible choice and they will want a new stadium in 15 years. Problem is that the Lindners don't want anything to do with Kentucky

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Newport is a much better choice. Keep it downtown. If you cant do OTR, go to Ovation. Oakley will be a horrible choice and they will want a new stadium in 15 years. Problem is that the Lindners don't want anything to do with Kentucky

I agree that Newport would be better then Oakley but you're right it's clear the ownership groups wants to build in Cincy.  Why do you think Oakley would want a new stadium in 15 years?  Wherever they build they're now going to spend over 300 million on this stadium.  You do some normal upkeep and upgrades on it over the years and this stadium is going to last a long time.  Just look at Great American Ballpark.  It's been opened 15 years and still seems relatively new because the Castellini's have been keeping it updated over the years. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Newport, IMO, was the worst choice and has always been the backup plan. Oakley has traffic issues that will need to be fixed. But with Mad Tree and all the other bars along Madison Road they'll be great places to pre-game at and march in. Oakley was always my 2nd choice to the West End but it's a great location and I'm excited.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Newport is the best choice. People who are saying “But that’s not Cincinnati” are giving in to kind of a knee jerk emotion.

 

West End/OTR is unworkable I think. The required large scale infrastructure is just out of step with the neighborhood.

 

I think developing a great atmosphere around an Oakley stadium is going to be a challenge.  Think about what MLS could be in 5-10 years. At that point you want the downtown infrastructure- hotels and restaurants- to be able to serve traveling fans. The skyline TV shots of Cincinnati would be attractive too.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I am not sure how you execute this plan without some reconfiguration of that Ridge exit (or some other additional access to 71/Norwood Lateral).

 

 

Developers in that area want that stuff reconfigured.  Cranley-funded improvements, ostensibly for the stadium, will be giveaways to his cronies.  Look for multiple Castellini-Cinti State viaducts.   

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'm a huge proponent of our brothers in Cincy getting a third professional team... However, I do think the timing is inconvenient.

 

The MLS does particularly well in spurts around the World Cup. Without US involvement this year, I am interested to see how the country turns to MLS. You've all proven that you can be a viable fan-base, but the climate for soccer in the country seems to be at a (temporary) plateau.

 

I would love to see the stadium go next to PBS in lieu of those warehouses and gravel lots where Bengals fans tailgate. However, I know that's not in the proposal right now, just saying.

 

This Clevelander is pulling for a thriving MLS market in Cincy.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Newport is a much better choice. Keep it downtown. If you cant do OTR, go to Ovation. Oakley will be a horrible choice and they will want a new stadium in 15 years. Problem is that the Lindners don't want anything to do with Kentucky

I agree that Newport would be better then Oakley but you're right it's clear the ownership groups wants to build in Cincy.  Why do you think Oakley would want a new stadium in 15 years?  Wherever they build they're now going to spend over 300 million on this stadium.  You do some normal upkeep and upgrades on it over the years and this stadium is going to last a long time.  Just look at Great American Ballpark.  It's been opened 15 years and still seems relatively new because the Castellini's have been keeping it updated over the years. 

 

I think in 15 years there will be a push to get more to the city center and downtown. The nice thing about Oakely though is that it is walkable.

Newport is the best choice. People who are saying But thats not Cincinnati are giving in to kind of a knee jerk emotion.

 

West End/OTR is unworkable I think. The required large scale infrastructure is just out of step with the neighborhood.

 

I think developing a great atmosphere around an Oakley stadium is going to be a challenge.  Think about what MLS could be in 5-10 years. At that point you want the downtown infrastructure- hotels and restaurants- to be able to serve traveling fans. The skyline TV shots of Cincinnati would be attractive too.

 

Berding came out the other week and pretty much said the only reason why Ovation has not been finalized is that the ownership group is from Ohio and they want to exhaust every last effort to keep it in Ohio first and foremost.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Obviously putting the stadium downtown would be preferable but there's just no room.  I still think they could squeeze it in next to the casino but that ship has seemingly sailed.  They really did not use that land very well around the casino.  There's a bunch of dead space that if reconfigured could easily fit a new soccer stadium or basketball arena. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I am not sure how you execute this plan without some reconfiguration of that Ridge exit (or some other additional access to 71/Norwood Lateral).

 

 

Developers in that area want that stuff reconfigured.  Cranley-funded improvements, ostensibly for the stadium, will be giveaways to his cronies.  Look for multiple Castellini-Cinti State viaducts.   

 

My first thought as well, and probably the biggest reason this didnt come out one or two days earlier as it played into one of the biggest complaints about him. This is the same area that the Mayor said, "beggars cant be choosers" when the developer he is friendly to changed from the original mixed residential walkable neighborhood proposal to a sea of parking and big box stores after approval. More of the same I'm afraid, but hopefully the land value increases to the point that the parking is repurposed into garages and the land better developed into what was originally promised. All profits going to his buddies of course but at least Oakley will be better of than the current situation there. Wasnt one of the complaints of the anti streetcar folk that it was just a ploy to increase the value of a house (houses) that Roxanne Qualls owned in OTR?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I am not sure how you execute this plan without some reconfiguration of that Ridge exit (or some other additional access to 71/Norwood Lateral).

 

 

Developers in that area want that stuff reconfigured.  Cranley-funded improvements, ostensibly for the stadium, will be giveaways to his cronies.  Look for multiple Castellini-Cinti State viaducts.   

 

My first thought as well, and probably the biggest reason this didnt come out one or two days earlier as it played into one of the biggest complaints about him. This is the same area that the Mayor said, "beggars cant be choosers" when the developer he is friendly to changed from the original mixed residential walkable neighborhood proposal to a sea of parking and big box stores after approval. More of the same I'm afraid, but hopefully the land value increases to the point that the parking is repurposed into garages and the land better developed into what was originally promised. All profits going to his buddies of course but at least Oakley will be better of than the current situation there. Wasnt one of the complaints of the anti streetcar folk that it was just a ploy to increase the value of a house (houses) that Roxanne Qualls owned in OTR?

 

Roxanne is a realtor. It was the value of the properties listed with her.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The Oakley site's biggest flaw is the traffic cluster it will create as there are really only three ways to the site. This will be compounded by the fact that Crossroads already has a huge crowd for their Saturday night service.

 

Strangely bus access to the area is okay with two crosstown routes terminating there. The bad news is that it's a long bus ride and they'll get stuck in the same game day traffic as everyone else.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Maybe the stadium will be the impetus for tearing down the big box stores and replacing them with mixed used, walkable development over time. You know, how it should've been built in the first place.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'm a huge proponent of our brothers in Cincy getting a third professional team... However, I do think the timing is inconvenient.

 

The MLS does particularly well in spurts around the World Cup. Without US involvement this year, I am interested to see how the country turns to MLS. You've all proven that you can be a viable fan-base, but the climate for soccer in the country seems to be at a (temporary) plateau.

 

Another point of view....Cincy is proof that their support for soccer goes well beyond MLS. Even if MLS ultimately fails there still exists a demand for professional teams. FCC can last as long as the good folks of the city (and Newport, I hope lol) want them to. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Does anyone else think that a FCC stadium could potentially provide enough fuel to the fire to potentially create a more condense big box site, but that's more urban to the akin of something you would see in Brooklyn/NYC?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Does anyone else think that a FCC stadium could potentially provide enough fuel to the fire to potentially create a more condense big box site, but that's more urban to the akin of something you would see in Brooklyn/NYC?

 

With a decent Mayor and Council... yes. With this current crop... no faith.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

https://www.google.com/maps/@39.1565202,-84.4390505,795m/data=!3m1!1e3

 

We'll likely see a solidification of the rumored plan to build an access road along the east side of I-71 extending Edwards first to Robertson and then either over or under the B&O tracks to the Oakley Station site. 

 

The other, and possibly quite destructive option, would be a connection between Norwood's Park Ave. and so-called Vandercaar Way.  This would require demolition of the historic Cincinnati Playing Card building and a new bridge over I-71. 

 

https://www.google.com/maps/@39.1611581,-84.4362395,1589m/data=!3m1!1e3

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

All of this money and infrastructure just to support a stadium that MIGHT get the FC in the MLS seems so incredibly stupid. FCC games are already a ton of fun, and their crowds help provide business to the places around UC that could definitely use the business bump in the summer months when the kids aren't there. The parking already exists, and fans seem to really love Nippert.

 

My question, then, is why the hell are we building yet another stadium to try to get to MLS? What benefit does the MLS bring? Cincinnati is already a major league city, and has been for years. We don't 'need' an MLS team in the way that a city like Columbus does to prove that we are a big league town. Furthermore, I don't think the presence of the MLS does much at all to advance the recognition of the city on a national stage- people simply don't care about it like they do NFL, NBA, or MLB.

 

We could potentially be squandering a redevelopment site that could house and/or employ tons of people so we can build a stadium and parking facilities that will be used a handful of times per year. We're introducing extreme traffic into one of the City's most desirable parts of town, and placing a stadium in a location where there could be very little spin off development. All for what? To feed the egos of the Lindners and other team owners? To help placate an inferiority complex of Cincinnatians who are desperate for external validation that their city is big and important? I genuinely don't get it.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

All of this money and infrastructure just to support a stadium that MIGHT get the FC in the MLS seems so incredibly stupid. FCC games are already a ton of fun, and their crowds help provide business to the places around UC that could definitely use the business bump in the summer months when the kids aren't there. The parking already exists, and fans seem to really love Nippert.

 

My question, then, is why the hell are we building yet another stadium to try to get to MLS? What benefit does the MLS bring? Cincinnati is already a major league city, and has been for years. We don't 'need' an MLS team in the way that a city like Columbus does to prove that we are a big league town. Furthermore, I don't think the presence of the MLS does much at all to advance the recognition of the city on a national stage- people simply don't care about it like they do NFL, NBA, or MLB.

 

We could potentially be squandering a redevelopment site that could house and/or employ tons of people so we can build a stadium and parking facilities that will be used a handful of times per year. We're introducing extreme traffic into one of the City's most desirable parts of town, and placing a stadium in a location where there could be very little spin off development. All for what? To feed the egos of the Lindners and other team owners? To help placate an inferiority complex of Cincinnatians who are desperate for external validation that their city is big and important? I genuinely don't get it.

 

Fans want to see top level play and top international players from around the world playing for FCC. You will never have that by staying in the usl. The usl is very much akin to AAA baseball team. It's lower level of play and the young players that do succeed leave for the mls.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

All of this money and infrastructure just to support a stadium that MIGHT get the FC in the MLS seems so incredibly stupid.

 

If MLS doesn't award a bid to Cincinnati, this stadium won't be built.

 

We could potentially be squandering a redevelopment site that could house and/or employ tons of people

 

Take a look at the current development and the leadership who brought that forward. It's the same leadership after Tuesday's election. We're not missing out. I'll roll the dice with a stadium (should MLS award a bid) rather than making room for a Chili's, Applebee's, Buffalo Wings and Things, etc.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

It's also of note that Jeff Berding said that it won't be just a stadium. Apparently they will also be developing the site next to the stadium as well for mixed use development. I'm guessing something along the lines of a mini banks with restaurants, bars, maybe a hotel, etc.

 

This could be a huge win for Oakley in the long run. Yes, with our current administration nothing will change with Oakley. But what about 20-30 years down the road? (I'll be 40-50 years old at that point.) Perhaps a stadium, with an urban mixed use development site next to the stadium could be a nice blueprint for the future of oakley...and maybe, just maybe, FCC can create a cataylst for a revision of Oakley. Again, not now, maybe not 10 years from now, but definitely maybe in my future, and for the millenials of cincinnati like me.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I won't go to any soccer games in Oakley.  I could  take the bus or even walk to the Nippert games and loved the atmosphere. I'm kindof a borderline fan anyway, and I'm only going to events that are within bike or walk range.  It was fun while it lasted.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I won't go to any soccer games in Oakley.  I could  take the bus or even walk to the Nippert games and loved the atmosphere. I'm kindof a borderline fan anyway, and I'm only going to events that are within bike or walk range.  It was fun while it lasted.

 

Interesting take. I wonder what percentage of fans will be willing to pay MLS ticket prices?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I am coming around to Oakley some. While I prefer Newport, there is better infrastructure in Oakley with the bars and character and will have the closest feel to Nippert from the beginning as opposed to Newport which would take time to develop

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I won't go to any soccer games in Oakley.  I could  take the bus or even walk to the Nippert games and loved the atmosphere. I'm kindof a borderline fan anyway, and I'm only going to events that are within bike or walk range.  It was fun while it lasted.

 

You could still bike or bus to Oakley? Rt. 11 runs on Madison and the other branch will also serve the new transit center. Also, two crosstown routes will serve that center. Madison's also a fairly good road to ride on. Not sure where your commuting from though.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Oakley certainly does not have the volume of bars / restaurants as the Uptown area but to be fair there is MadTree, Oak Tavern, Oakley Pub, Habits, RP McMurphy's, Animations, The E and a few chain places.

 

Additionally, Jeff Berding had indicated they want to activate the space around the stadium as a mixed use area so if everything comes together then there would be additional options around the stadium not just a parking lot.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I won't go to any soccer games in Oakley.  I could  take the bus or even walk to the Nippert games and loved the atmosphere. I'm kindof a borderline fan anyway, and I'm only going to events that are within bike or walk range.  It was fun while it lasted.

 

You could still bike or bus to Oakley? Rt. 11 runs on Madison and the other branch will also serve the new transit center. Also, two crosstown routes will serve that center. Madison's also a fairly good road to ride on. Not sure where your commuting from though.

 

Yeah but its still so much farther away via transit. To Madtree is about a half hour on the Rt. 11. If you are coming from Westwood or Northside via either Rt. 41 or 51 its basically riding almost the entirety of those lines across town.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Are we going to march from the IHOP, Target, Meijer's or Sam's Club?

 

Olive Garden!

 

Yeah but its still so much farther away via transit. To Madtree is about a half hour on the Rt. 11. If you are coming from Westwood or Northside via either Rt. 41 or 51 its basically riding almost the entirety of those lines across town.

 

This is very true.

 

My hope would be that maybe the stadium would be an impetus or encouraging factor to offer more frequent service or maybe some sort of revised route.

 

In an ideal world, I'd love to see Oakley Square closed off to only pedestrians and transit. Make it an open container zone so as the bars don't need to get over-crowded. Build a pedestrian bridge from 34th/Enyart to connect directly to the stadium.

 

Alas, it's all wishful thinking.

 

Oakley isn't my first choice either.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Any connections to that site through to the rest of Oakley or Norwood will have the residents there up in arms. This is near the same area that had streets connecting to Edwards cut off because of Rookwood traffic.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Any connections to that site through to the rest of Oakley or Norwood will have the residents there up in arms. This is near the same area that had streets connecting to Edwards cut off because of Rookwood traffic.

Yeah... connecting Oakley Square to the stadium will be tricky due to the nature of the neighborhood between Madison and Robertson.

 

North of Robertson, there is the 30-acre site owned by Oakley Yard LLC. Anybody know what that facility is used for? That land could be very valuable if integrated into a *properly designed* mixed use district. Most of the Oakley Yard site is single-story warehouse, so probably not worth saving... but there is a 4-story older building that I could imagine being re-purposed into condos/apartments. They would need to figure out where/how to cross the railroad tracks. 34th Ave seems like a natural place to have a crossing.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Oakley certainly does not have the volume of bars / restaurants as the Uptown area but to be fair there is MadTree, Oak Tavern, Oakley Pub, Habits, RP McMurphy's, Animations, The E and a few chain places.

 

 

 

I vote for Slammer's.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Somebody just reviewed it on the Goog 3 weeks ago complaining that they weren't allowed to take over the jukebox with 10 bucks.

 

People will drop $10 to play the entirety of Hillbilly Deluxe next but won't pay $10 to physically own Hillbilly Deluxe

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

×